PAPA Contractors DirectoryPennsylvania · one directory, every trade

← Home · Roofers · York County  ·  pacontractorhub.com/pa/shrewsbury/roofers/

Last updated: November 22, 2026

Best Roofers in Shrewsbury, PA — Full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000

A roofer installing asphalt shingles on a suburban house roof
A roofing contractor at work — general trade photo for this category, not a photo of any listed business.

1 verified roofers based in Shrewsbury, plus 3 more based nearby who state they cover Shrewsbury. Every listing has a confirmed address and phone; the town filter matches base town and stated service areas, so nobody is listed twice.

The best roofers in Shrewsbury, PA, according to this directory's published methodology, are TC Backer Construction LLC, The Grace Family Roofing Company and Shiloh Roofing. They were picked from 4 verified listings by confirmed rating weighted by review count. Key fact: full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000. Every listing has a confirmed address and phone number; listings last verified Nov 20–22, 2026. This is the most comprehensive listing of verified roofers in Shrewsbury, PA — 4 verified businesses with phone numbers, services, and prices.

Our Recommended Top 3

We did the research for you. We scored Shrewsbury on address & phone verification, confirmed ratings, published credentials, and stated service areas across four categories — then hand-picked the best.✓ Address & phone verified   ✓ Confirmed ratings   ✓ Credentials where published

4Reviewed
4Curated
3Top Picks

Listings last verified Nov 20–22, 2026 · York County · ZIPs in town listings: 17361 · Ratings confirmed as of Nov 2026

Top Picks in Shrewsbury

Chosen by the published methodology.
★ Top Pick

Chosen on verification strength: GAF Master Elite · lists emergency service

Roofing Contractor — York, PA

TC Backer Construction LLC

Covering: York, Dover, Hanover, Dallastown, Red Lion, West York +2 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2300 Carlisle Rd, York, PA 17408

GAF Master EliteCertainTeed ShingleMasterCertainTeed 5-Star SidingPA081829Emergency service

Roof repair · Roof replacement · Roof installation · Emergency roof repair · Roof maintenance · +4 more

Why choose this provider?

TC Backer Construction LLC is a verified roofing contractor based in York, PA that gAF Master Elite, certainTeed ShingleMaster, explicitly lists emergency service.

Roof repairRoof replacementRoof installation

Family-owned. GAF Golden Pledge Warranty. Community Choice Best Roofer 4 years running. 24/7 availability per own site. Also has a Dover office (1550 E Canal Rd, Dover, PA 17315, (717) 949-7673) — listed in notes only. Alternate site tcbacker.com. Rating not Places-verified (directories cite 4.9/276).

★ Top Pick

Chosen on verification strength: GAF Master Elite

Roofing Contractor — Shrewsbury, PA

The Grace Family Roofing Company

Covering: Shrewsbury, York, Hanover, Dallastown, Red Lion, West York +3 more

No verified rating yet

📍 232 N Main St, Shrewsbury, PA 17361

GAF Master EliteCertainTeed ShingleMasterNRCA member20+ years in business

Residential roof replacement · Roof installation · Roof repairs · Asphalt shingle roofing · Metal roofing · +9 more

Why choose this provider?

The Grace Family Roofing Company is a verified roofing contractor based in Shrewsbury, PA that gAF Master Elite, certainTeed ShingleMaster.

Residential roof replacementRoof installationRoof repairs

4th-generation family roofer since 1924; 20+ years hands-on experience. 25-year workmanship warranty; military & first responder discounts. Site says 'fully licensed' but no license number found — recorded null. Rating not Places-verified (directories cite 5.0/108–117 Google).

★ Top Pick

Chosen on verification strength: GAF-authorized · lists emergency service

Roofing Contractor — York, PA

Shiloh Roofing

Covering: York, Hanover, Gettysburg, Dallastown, Red Lion, Dover +3 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2517 Sunset Ln, York, PA 17408

GAF-authorizedNRCA memberPA008791Emergency service

Residential roofing · Commercial roofing · Roof replacement · Roof repair · Asphalt shingle roofing · +9 more

Why choose this provider?

Shiloh Roofing is a verified roofing contractor based in York, PA that gAF-authorized, nRCA member, explicitly lists emergency service.

Residential roofingCommercial roofingRoof replacement

Second-generation family-owned, same location since 1957. BBB A+. License HIC#8791 per own site. 24/7 emergency response per directories. 10-year workmanship guarantee. BBB also lists a second address, 668 Rishel Dr, York, PA 17406.

All verified roofers serving Shrewsbury

Roofing Contractor — York, PA

American Remodeling Enterprises Inc

Covering: York, Shiloh, Red Lion, Dallastown, Shrewsbury, Dover +4 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2217 Carlisle Rd, Ste 406, York, PA 17408

GAF CertifiedPA004002

Residential roof replacement · Roof installation · Commercial roofing · Asphalt shingle roofing · Metal roofing · +6 more

Residential roof replacementRoof installationCommercial roofing

Family-owned since 1982; HQ in Schuylkill Haven (57 Saint James St) with York and Selinsgrove offices. BBB A+ (accredited since 2014); Qualified Remodeler Top 500 #160 (2025). License PA004002 exp 7/1/2027 per BBB. Own-site phone used; BuildZoom lists toll-free (833) 243-8786. Site lists 24/7 hours (likely a widget default) — recorded null. Rating not Places-verified (own site claims 4.9/128 Google).

Roofing Contractor — York, PA

Shiloh Roofing

Covering: York, Hanover, Gettysburg, Dallastown, Red Lion, Dover +3 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2517 Sunset Ln, York, PA 17408

GAF-authorizedNRCA memberPA008791Emergency service

Residential roofing · Commercial roofing · Roof replacement · Roof repair · Asphalt shingle roofing · +9 more

Residential roofingCommercial roofingRoof replacement

Second-generation family-owned, same location since 1957. BBB A+. License HIC#8791 per own site. 24/7 emergency response per directories. 10-year workmanship guarantee. BBB also lists a second address, 668 Rishel Dr, York, PA 17406.

Roofing Contractor — York, PA

TC Backer Construction LLC

Covering: York, Dover, Hanover, Dallastown, Red Lion, West York +2 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2300 Carlisle Rd, York, PA 17408

GAF Master EliteCertainTeed ShingleMasterCertainTeed 5-Star SidingPA081829Emergency service

Roof repair · Roof replacement · Roof installation · Emergency roof repair · Roof maintenance · +4 more

Roof repairRoof replacementRoof installation

Family-owned. GAF Golden Pledge Warranty. Community Choice Best Roofer 4 years running. 24/7 availability per own site. Also has a Dover office (1550 E Canal Rd, Dover, PA 17315, (717) 949-7673) — listed in notes only. Alternate site tcbacker.com. Rating not Places-verified (directories cite 4.9/276).

Roofing Contractor — Shrewsbury, PA

The Grace Family Roofing Company

Covering: Shrewsbury, York, Hanover, Dallastown, Red Lion, West York +3 more

No verified rating yet

📍 232 N Main St, Shrewsbury, PA 17361

GAF Master EliteCertainTeed ShingleMasterNRCA member20+ years in business

Residential roof replacement · Roof installation · Roof repairs · Asphalt shingle roofing · Metal roofing · +9 more

Residential roof replacementRoof installationRoof repairs

4th-generation family roofer since 1924; 20+ years hands-on experience. 25-year workmanship warranty; military & first responder discounts. Site says 'fully licensed' but no license number found — recorded null. Rating not Places-verified (directories cite 5.0/108–117 Google).

Roofers serving Shrewsbury — on the map

Each business below, pinned at its base town. Businesses based elsewhere that state they cover Shrewsbury are pinned at their own base town.

Pins sit at town centers and show base towns, not exact street addresses — the confirmed street address is on each listing card. Map © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Roofers at a glance

Every verified listing on this page, side by side.

BusinessRatingBase townPhoneEmergency
American Remodeling Enterprises IncNo verified rating yetYork+1 717-268-9020Not stated
Shiloh RoofingNo verified rating yetYork+1 717-764-1269Listed
TC Backer Construction LLCNo verified rating yetYork+1 717-837-5456Listed
The Grace Family Roofing CompanyNo verified rating yetShrewsbury+1 717-578-7222Not stated

What roofers cost in PA — 2026

Researched Nov 20–22, 2026. Planning ranges (labor + materials), not quotes. “PA” rows are Pennsylvania–sourced.

JobTypical rangeScopeSourceBasis
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle$6,300–$20,000Typical home; resident.com low end is smaller/standard jobs, Discounted Roofing's high end is 1,500–2,000 sq ft architectural shingleresident.com, Jun 26, 2026; Discounted Roofing LLC (Philadelphia), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle, PittsburghMedian ~$13,100; middle half $9,500–$17,900; 9 in 10 under $25,900425 replacements, Nov 2024–Oct 2026Big Fish Roofing (Pittsburgh contractor data), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle, by home sizeSmall $8,000–$12,000; average $12,000–$18,000; larger $18,000–$30,000+PA average asphalt shingleCarranza Roofing (Facebook ad), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — shingle (regional contractor band)$13,000–$35,000Complete shingle replacements; pitch, square footage, and layer tear-offs drive the rangePorter Family Exteriors site, Nov 2026PA
Metal roof replacement (2,000 sq ft)$11,500–$36,800Installed; standing seam $12–$20/sq ft at the high endgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Tile roof replacement (2,000 sq ft)$16,100–$57,500Installedgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Flat roof replacement — rowhouse$4,000–$5,000 typical; wider band $4,500–$12,000Small rowhouse flat roofs; EPDM $5–$9/sq ft, TPO $6–$12/sq ftresident.com, Jun 26, 2026; Discounted Roofing LLC, Nov 2026PA
Flat roof replacement (1,000 sq ft)$3,450–$12,650Installed membranegoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Tear-off of one old layer (2,000 sq ft)$2,300–$4,600Removal onlygoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Minor roof repair / leak repair$175–$1,150Small leak, few shingles, minor flashing resealgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Roof repair — general (Philadelphia)$300–$1,500Common repairs: shingles, flat-roof seam, chimney flashingUnion Roofing (own site), Nov 2026PA
Leak with water damage$1,150–$6,900Repair + damaged decking/interiorgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Flashing repair$230–$575Chimney / vent flashinggoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Vent boot repair$86–$175Single vent bootgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Replace up to 25 shingles$115–$345Shingle-only repairgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Roof deck repair$230–$575 per 100 sq ftDecking replacementgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Gutter-only job (median)~$1,600Pittsburgh median, gutter-only workBig Fish Roofing, Nov 2026PA

⚠️ Sources disagree: resident.com puts a typical Philadelphia replacement at $6,300–$10,900, Discounted Roofing LLC at $8,000–$20,000, and Porter Family Exteriors at $13,000–$35,000 for complete shingle replacements in the Philadelphia suburbs. The gap is scope and grade — the $6,300–$20,000 headline covers standard jobs; Porter's band is the premium, large-home end. Pittsburgh's median of ~$13,100 sits inside the headline band.

Shrewsbury — frequently asked questions

How many verified roofers serve Shrewsbury?

4 — 1 based in Shrewsbury and 3 covering it from nearby towns. Only businesses with a confirmed address and phone are listed.

Why do some listings say “No verified rating yet”?

No confirmed rating was found for those businesses during verification, so the card says so instead of showing a guess. Their address and phone are still confirmed.

How many offer emergency service?

2 of the 4 listings explicitly state emergency service. Call first — hours and emergency coverage change.

What do roofers charge in Shrewsbury?

Full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000. The full sourced cost table is above — ranges are planning figures researched Nov 20–22, 2026, not quotes.

How are the Top Picks chosen?

By the published methodology: rated businesses ranked by rating weighted by review count, then verification strength (certifications, license numbers, years in business).

Also in Shrewsbury

Browse nearby towns

0 shortlisted
Top Pick: TC Backer Construction LLC · York📞 Call +1 717-837-5456