PAPA Contractors DirectoryPennsylvania · one directory, every trade

← Home · Roofers · Allegheny County  ·  pacontractorhub.com/pa/carnegie/roofers/

Last updated: November 22, 2026

Best Roofers in Carnegie, PA — Full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000

A roofer installing asphalt shingles on a suburban house roof
A roofing contractor at work — general trade photo for this category, not a photo of any listed business.

1 verified roofers based in Carnegie, plus 5 more based nearby who state they cover Carnegie. Every listing has a confirmed address and phone; the town filter matches base town and stated service areas, so nobody is listed twice.

The best roofers in Carnegie, PA, according to this directory's published methodology, are Big Fish Roofing, Resnick Roofing & Contracting and MHI Roofing. They were picked from 6 verified listings by confirmed rating weighted by review count (3 of the 6 have confirmed ratings). Key fact: full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000. Every listing has a confirmed address and phone number; listings last verified Nov 20–22, 2026. This is the most comprehensive listing of verified roofers in Carnegie, PA — 6 verified businesses with phone numbers, services, and prices.

Our Recommended Top 3

We did the research for you. We scored Carnegie on address & phone verification, confirmed ratings, published credentials, and stated service areas across four categories — then hand-picked the best.✓ Address & phone verified   ✓ Confirmed ratings   ✓ Credentials where published

6Reviewed
6Curated
3Top Picks

Listings last verified Nov 20–22, 2026 · Allegheny County · ZIPs in town listings: 15106 · Ratings confirmed as of Nov 2026

Top Picks in Carnegie

Chosen by the published methodology.
★ Top Pick

4.9 ★ from 40 confirmed reviews — highest rating-confidence here

Roofing Contractor — Morgan, PA

Big Fish Roofing

Covering: Morgan, Pittsburgh, Bethel Park, Canonsburg, Bridgeville, Carnegie +2 more

★★★★★ 4.9 (40 Google reviews)

📍 202 W Bridge Dr, Morgan, PA 15064

GAF Master ElitePA119464

Roof replacement · Metal roofing · Residential roofing · Commercial roofing · Roof installation · +5 more

Why choose this provider?

Big Fish Roofing is a verified roofing contractor based in Morgan, PA that holds a confirmed 4.9 rating from 40 reviews, gAF Master Elite, pA119464.

Roof replacementMetal roofingResidential roofing

GAF Master Elite, 3-Star President's Club; A+ BBB; 12-year workmanship warranty.

★ Top Pick

5.0 ★ from 10 confirmed reviews — highest rating-confidence here

Roofing Contractor — Gibsonia, PA

Resnick Roofing & Contracting

Covering: Gibsonia, Allison Park, Aspinwall, Ambridge, Avalon, Baden +93 more

★★★★★ 5.0 (10 Google reviews)

📍 5320 William Flinn Hwy, Gibsonia, PA 15044

GAF Master ElitePA137482

Roof replacement · Metal roofing · Roof repair · Seamless gutter replacement · Box gutters · +4 more

Why choose this provider?

Resnick Roofing & Contracting is a verified roofing contractor based in Gibsonia, PA that holds a confirmed 5.0 rating from 10 reviews, gAF Master Elite, pA137482.

Roof replacementMetal roofingRoof repair

GAF Master Elite, President's Club; A+ BBB; locally owned; solar shingle installations.

★ Top Pick

5.0 ★ from 4 confirmed reviews — highest rating-confidence here

Roofing Contractor — Coraopolis, PA

MHI Roofing

Covering: Pittsburgh, Allison Park, Baldwin, Bethel Park, Bridgeville, Carnegie +8 more

★★★★★ 5.0 (4 Google reviews)

📍 314 Moon Clinton Rd, Coraopolis, PA 15108

GAF Master Elite

Roof replacement · Roof repair · Roof inspections

Why choose this provider?

MHI Roofing is a verified roofing contractor based in Coraopolis, PA that holds a confirmed 5.0 rating from 4 reviews, gAF Master Elite.

Roof replacementRoof repairRoof inspections

Serving Pittsburgh since 1979; GAF Master Elite, 3-Star President's Club; BBB A+; 21-point inspection.

All verified roofers serving Carnegie

Roofing Contractor — Morgan, PA

Big Fish Roofing

Covering: Morgan, Pittsburgh, Bethel Park, Canonsburg, Bridgeville, Carnegie +2 more

★★★★★ 4.9 (40 Google reviews)

📍 202 W Bridge Dr, Morgan, PA 15064

GAF Master ElitePA119464

Roof replacement · Metal roofing · Residential roofing · Commercial roofing · Roof installation · +5 more

Roof replacementMetal roofingResidential roofing

GAF Master Elite, 3-Star President's Club; A+ BBB; 12-year workmanship warranty.

Roofing Contractor — Gibsonia, PA

Resnick Roofing & Contracting

Covering: Gibsonia, Allison Park, Aspinwall, Ambridge, Avalon, Baden +93 more

★★★★★ 5.0 (10 Google reviews)

📍 5320 William Flinn Hwy, Gibsonia, PA 15044

GAF Master ElitePA137482

Roof replacement · Metal roofing · Roof repair · Seamless gutter replacement · Box gutters · +4 more

Roof replacementMetal roofingRoof repair

GAF Master Elite, President's Club; A+ BBB; locally owned; solar shingle installations.

Roofing Contractor — Coraopolis, PA

MHI Roofing

Covering: Pittsburgh, Allison Park, Baldwin, Bethel Park, Bridgeville, Carnegie +8 more

★★★★★ 5.0 (4 Google reviews)

📍 314 Moon Clinton Rd, Coraopolis, PA 15108

GAF Master Elite

Roof replacement · Roof repair · Roof inspections

Roof replacementRoof repairRoof inspections

Serving Pittsburgh since 1979; GAF Master Elite, 3-Star President's Club; BBB A+; 21-point inspection.

Roofing Contractor — Pittsburgh, PA

MY Pittsburgh Roofing

Covering: Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, Butler County, Beaver County, Wexford, Gibsonia +23 more

No verified rating yet

📍 4560 McKnight Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15237

GAF Master Elite

Roof replacement · Metal roofing · Roof repairs · Roof inspections · Siding installation & repairs · +1 more

Roof replacementMetal roofingRoof repairs

Locally owned; GAF Master Elite; BBB A+; free estimates.

Roofing Contractor — Oakdale, PA

McClellands Contracting and Roofing, LLC

Covering: Allegheny County, Washington County, Beaver County, Butler County, Pittsburgh, Bridgeville +26 more

No verified rating yet

📍 2 Industrial Park Dr, Oakdale, PA 15071

GAF Master EliteEmergency service

Roof replacement · Roof repair · Roof installation · Roof inspection · Asphalt shingles · +5 more

Roof replacementRoof repairRoof installation

GAF Master Elite; BBB A+; 24/7 emergency service; Christian-owned local business.

Roofing Contractor — Carnegie, PA

Wm. Prescott Roofing & Remodeling

Based in: Carnegie — no wider service area stated in sources

No verified rating yet

📍 20 W Noblestown Rd, Carnegie, PA 15106

GAF Master Elite

Residential roofing · Roof repairs · Commercial roofing · Siding installation · Skylight installation · +3 more

Residential roofingRoof repairsCommercial roofing

Family-owned since 1906; BBB A+; GAF President's Club; pre-war and historic home specialist.

Roofers serving Carnegie — on the map

Each business below, pinned at its base town. Businesses based elsewhere that state they cover Carnegie are pinned at their own base town.

Pins sit at town centers and show base towns, not exact street addresses — the confirmed street address is on each listing card. Map © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Roofers at a glance

Every verified listing on this page, side by side.

BusinessRatingBase townPhoneEmergency
Big Fish Roofing4.9 (40 reviews)Morgan+1 724-395-7630Not stated
Resnick Roofing & Contracting5.0 (10 reviews)Gibsonia+1 412-213-6535Not stated
MHI Roofing5.0 (4 reviews)Coraopolis+1 412-912-2710Not stated
MY Pittsburgh RoofingNo verified rating yetPittsburgh+1 412-218-7082Not stated
McClellands Contracting and Roofing, LLCNo verified rating yetOakdale+1 412-353-5660Listed
Wm. Prescott Roofing & RemodelingNo verified rating yetCarnegie+1 412-991-2005Not stated

What roofers cost in PA — 2026

Researched Nov 20–22, 2026. Planning ranges (labor + materials), not quotes. “PA” rows are Pennsylvania–sourced.

JobTypical rangeScopeSourceBasis
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle$6,300–$20,000Typical home; resident.com low end is smaller/standard jobs, Discounted Roofing's high end is 1,500–2,000 sq ft architectural shingleresident.com, Jun 26, 2026; Discounted Roofing LLC (Philadelphia), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle, PittsburghMedian ~$13,100; middle half $9,500–$17,900; 9 in 10 under $25,900425 replacements, Nov 2024–Oct 2026Big Fish Roofing (Pittsburgh contractor data), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — asphalt shingle, by home sizeSmall $8,000–$12,000; average $12,000–$18,000; larger $18,000–$30,000+PA average asphalt shingleCarranza Roofing (Facebook ad), Nov 2026PA
Full roof replacement — shingle (regional contractor band)$13,000–$35,000Complete shingle replacements; pitch, square footage, and layer tear-offs drive the rangePorter Family Exteriors site, Nov 2026PA
Metal roof replacement (2,000 sq ft)$11,500–$36,800Installed; standing seam $12–$20/sq ft at the high endgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Tile roof replacement (2,000 sq ft)$16,100–$57,500Installedgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Flat roof replacement — rowhouse$4,000–$5,000 typical; wider band $4,500–$12,000Small rowhouse flat roofs; EPDM $5–$9/sq ft, TPO $6–$12/sq ftresident.com, Jun 26, 2026; Discounted Roofing LLC, Nov 2026PA
Flat roof replacement (1,000 sq ft)$3,450–$12,650Installed membranegoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Tear-off of one old layer (2,000 sq ft)$2,300–$4,600Removal onlygoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Minor roof repair / leak repair$175–$1,150Small leak, few shingles, minor flashing resealgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Roof repair — general (Philadelphia)$300–$1,500Common repairs: shingles, flat-roof seam, chimney flashingUnion Roofing (own site), Nov 2026PA
Leak with water damage$1,150–$6,900Repair + damaged decking/interiorgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Flashing repair$230–$575Chimney / vent flashinggoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Vent boot repair$86–$175Single vent bootgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Replace up to 25 shingles$115–$345Shingle-only repairgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Roof deck repair$230–$575 per 100 sq ftDecking replacementgoldgcp.com 2026 estimates (Philadelphia)PA
Gutter-only job (median)~$1,600Pittsburgh median, gutter-only workBig Fish Roofing, Nov 2026PA

⚠️ Sources disagree: resident.com puts a typical Philadelphia replacement at $6,300–$10,900, Discounted Roofing LLC at $8,000–$20,000, and Porter Family Exteriors at $13,000–$35,000 for complete shingle replacements in the Philadelphia suburbs. The gap is scope and grade — the $6,300–$20,000 headline covers standard jobs; Porter's band is the premium, large-home end. Pittsburgh's median of ~$13,100 sits inside the headline band.

Carnegie — frequently asked questions

How many verified roofers serve Carnegie?

6 — 1 based in Carnegie and 5 covering it from nearby towns. Only businesses with a confirmed address and phone are listed.

Who is the highest-rated roofer serving Carnegie?

Big Fish Roofing — 4.9 from 40 confirmed reviews (rating weighted by review count, per the methodology).

How many offer emergency service?

1 of the 6 listings explicitly state emergency service. Call first — hours and emergency coverage change.

What do roofers charge in Carnegie?

Full roof replacement $6,300–$20,000. The full sourced cost table is above — ranges are planning figures researched Nov 20–22, 2026, not quotes.

How are the Top Picks chosen?

By the published methodology: rated businesses ranked by rating weighted by review count, then verification strength (certifications, license numbers, years in business).

Also in Carnegie

Browse nearby towns

0 shortlisted
Top Pick: Big Fish Roofing · Morgan📞 Call +1 724-395-7630